- Roy Halladay (Phi) 10
- Tim Lincecum (SF) 9.5
- Felix Hernandez (Sea) 9.5
- CC Sabathia (NYY) 9
- Cliff Lee (Phi) 9
- Josh Johnson (Fla) 9
- Adam Wainright (Stl) 9
- Jon Lester (Bos) 8.5
- Justin Verlander (Det) 8.5
- David Price (TB) 8.5
- Zack Greinke (Mil) 8.25
- Cole Hamels (Phi) 8.25
- Jered Weaver (LAA) 8.25
- Ubaldo Jimenez (Col) 8.25
- Matt Cain (SF) 8
- Chris Carpenter (Stl) 8
- Trevor Cahill (Oak) 8
- John Lackey (Bos) 8
- Tommy Hanson (Atl) 8
- Mat Latos (SD) 8
- Francisco Liriano (Min)
- Dan Haren (LAA) 7.75
- Clayton Kershaw (LAD) 7.75
- Wandy Rodriguez (Hou) 7.75
- Yovani Gallardo (Mil) 7.75
- Roy Oswalt (Phi) 7.75
- Ricky Romero (Tor) 7.75
- Josh Beckett (Bos) 7.75
- Johan Santana (NYM) 7.75
- Tim Hudson (Atl) 7.75
- Max Scherzer (Det) 7.5
- Matt Garza (Chc) 7.5
- Clay Buchholz (Bos) 7.5
- Chad Billingsley (LAD) 7.5
- Madison Bumgarner (SF) 7.5
- John Danks (Chw) 7.5
- Brandon Morrow (Tor) 7.5
- Jeremy Hellickson (TB) 7.5
- Brett Anderson (Oak) 7.5
- Brett Myers (Hou) 7.5
- Mark Buehrle (Chw) 7.5
- Brandon Webb (Tex) 7.25
- Shaun Marcum (Tor) 7.25
- Hiroki Kuroda (LAD) 7.25
- Daniel Hudson (Ari) 7.25
- Gavin Floyd (Chw) 7.25
- Gio Gonzalez (Oak) 7.25
- Rick Porcello (Det) 7.25
- Brian Matusz (Bal) 7.25
- James Shields (TB) 7.25
- Carl Pavano (Min) 7.25
- Jeremy Guthrie (Bal) 7.25
- Johnny Cueto (Cin) 7.25
- Mike Pelfrey (NYM) 7.25
- Jake Peavy (Chw) 7.25
- Ian Kennedy (Ari) 7.25
- Derek Lowe (Atl) 7.25
- Wade Davis (TB) 7.25
- Phil Hughes (NYY) 7.25
- Joel Pineiro (LAA) 7.25
- Dallas Braden (Oak) 7.25
- C.J. Wilson (Tex) 7.25
- Jhoulys Chacin (Col) 7.25
- Jaime Garcia (Stl) 7.25
- Bronson Arroyo (Cin) 7.25
- Javier Vazquez (Fla) 7.25
- Scott Baker (Min) 7.25
- Jair Jurrjens (Atl) 7.25
- Kyle Drabek (Tor) 7.25
- Jonathan Sanchez (SF) 7.25
- Jon Garland (LAD) 7.25
- Edwin Jackson (Det) 7.25
- Edinson Volquez (Cin) 7.25
- Brian Duensing (Min) 7.25
- Carlos Zambrano (Chc) 7.25
- Ervin Santana (LAA) 7.25
- Fausto Carmona (Cle) 7.25
- R.A. Dickey (NYM) 7.25
- Clayton Richard (SD) 7.25
- Jorge De La Rosa (Col) 7.25
- Ricky Nolasco (Fla) 7.25
- Annibal Sanchez (Fla) 7.25
- J.A. Happ (Hou) 7.25
- A.J. Burnett (NYY) 7
- Rich Harden (Oak) 7
- Homer Bailey (Cin) 7
- Travis Wood (Cin) 7
- Jeff Niemann (TB) 7
- Joe Blanton (Phi) 7
- James McDonald (Pit) 7
- Nick Blackburn (Min) 7
- Colby Lewis (Tex) 7
- Joe Saunders (Ari) 7
- Jake Westbrook (Stl) 7
- Randy Wolf (Mil) 7
- Jonathon Niese (NYM) 7
- Carlos Carrasco (Cle) 7
- Randy Wells (Chc) 7
- Jason Hammel (Col) 7
- Scott Kazmir (LAA) 7
